Why You Can Sing in Your Head but Forget the Words Out Loud
Have you ever noticed that you can sing every word of a song perfectly in your head, but the moment you open your mouth, it’s as if your brain’s hit pause? You know the words are there, but they vanish just when you need them.
You’re not alone, and there’s a fascinating reason why this happens, especially for autistic and ADHD brains.
The song is stored like a recording
When you hear a song over and over, your brain stores it as a pattern, not just the lyrics, but the rhythm, tone, and melody. That pattern lives in your auditory memory, which works a bit like pressing play on a recording. That’s why you can “hear” the song in your head even when there’s no music playing.
It’s automatic, effortless, and doesn’t need you to think about it.
Singing out loud is a different job altogether
As soon as you try to sing, the task moves from automatic memory to active production. Now your language areas have to recall every word, your motor cortex has to control your mouth and breathing, and your prefrontal cortex has to keep everything in time.
That’s a lot of coordination, and for neurodivergent brains, the jump from automatic recall to verbal output can feel like crossing a busy road full of distractions.
Working memory: the fragile bridge
Your working memory is the mental space that holds the next few words of a sentence (or song) while you’re saying the current ones. If working memory or sequencing skills are weaker, as is common in ADHD and autism, the bridge between knowing and producing words can wobble. The result? You “know” the song perfectly, but your mouth can’t quite keep up.
Overthinking breaks the flow
When you’re relaxed, your brain can run the lyrics automatically. But once you think about the words, your prefrontal cortex takes over, and that conscious control actually disrupts the smooth flow. It’s the same reason we sometimes freeze when asked to repeat something we know well, or why words vanish mid-sentence when someone’s watching.
The executive functioning connection
Executive functions are the brain’s management system; they organise, plan, sequence, and retrieve information. For those who are autistic and have ADHD, these functions can work differently, meaning even simple transitions, like moving from thinking to speaking, can take extra effort. It doesn’t mean we don’t know the information; it just means the pathway from storage to speech is more complex.
So next time it happens...
Remember, it’s not forgetfulness, and it’s not a flaw. Your brain simply works in layers. Inside your head, the song runs perfectly on autopilot. Out loud, it asks for conscious coordination, and that’s where things get tangled.
Understanding this difference can help us show more kindness to ourselves and to the children and adults who experience the same thing every day, whether it’s singing, speaking, or finding the right words under pressure.
Comments
Post a Comment